Holst: The Planets – Beni Mora – Japanese Suite – Andrew Davis – Chandos

Covers + lossless, Not my Rip


That “The Planets” occupies a place at the heart of the English musical repertoire is indisputable yet much of Holst’s other orchestral output is unjustly neglected. Chandos’ series demonstrates that Holst was a composer whose inventiveness and originality was not limited to one spectacular work. The series was originally to be conducted by Richard Hickox who sadly passed away in 2009 after completing Volume 1, released to great critical acclaim. Gramophone stated: “Richard Hickox’s final project, reviving little-known Holst works, is a triumph”.

In this second volume, exclusive Chandos artist Sir Andrew Davis has taken the baton, conducting the BBC Philharmonic in a unique programme: “The Planets”, Holst’s orchestral tour de force, as well as two comparative rarities in the concert hall, the lyrical and mysterious “Japanese Suite” and the equally dramatic “Beni Mora”.

Holst wrote all three works between 1909 and 1916, years which span the most important developments in his composing life as he moved away from the Wagner-influenced works of his youth. He had already begun to absorb English folk music, largely through the influences of his close friend Ralph Vaughan Williams, and that, together with his study of Sanskrit literature, led him to experiment with new and unique fusions in his music. The “Japanese Suite” was originally intended for dancing and composed at the request of a Japanese dancer, Michio Ito, who supplied Holst with most of the themes in a somewhat unorthodox manner – by whistling them to him. Although the music may seem as characteristic of Holst himself as of anything readily identifiable as Japanese, this work clearly demonstrates a refreshing openness to new influences, which few of his contemporaries shared.

“Beni Mora” is inspired by ethnic music that Holst heard on a trip to Algeria. Its orientalism may seem very westernized to those familiar with the original music, but it reflects his own experiences of the region which the notes describe as “a mix of East and West where one moment he saw an Arab woman leaving a mosque and another moment he saw an advertisement for American Cinematography”. The work was premiered in London in 1912, to the distaste of one critic who exclaimed, “We didn’t ask for Biskra girls”. Vaughan Williams later wrote that if the piece had been played in Paris instead of London, Holst would have gained fame a good ten years before “The Planets” made him a household name. One of the more remarkable musical points about the piece is found in the third movement, which is based on a motif played by a bamboo flutist whom Holst heard on the streets in Algeria. The flutist played the same four notes for hours. This experience is vividly recalled in the movement, yet the mastery of Holst’s shifting harmonic textures prevents the motif from becoming tiresome. Beni Mora is regarded as Holst’s first mature orchestral piece.

The immense popularity of “The Planets”, and the familiarity of the music, means that its originality is often overlooked. But while it is possible to point to a number of contemporary works which clearly had an influence on Holst (Debussy’s Nocturnes, Stravinsky’s The Firebird etc.), the sheer inventiveness and diversity of the music are entirely his own, as he takes us on an unforgettable journey from the violence of “Mars”, through the serene calm of “Venus” and the remote and otherworldly “Neptune”.

1. Beni Mora, Op. 29 no 1/H 107 by Gustav Holst
Conductor: Sir Andrew Davis
Orchestra/Ensemble: BBC Philharmonic Orchestra
Written: 1909-1910; England
Date of Recording: June 24/25, 2010
Venue: Bridgewater Hall, Manchester, UK
Length: 16 Minutes 50 Secs.

2. Japanese Suite, Op. 33/H 126 by Gustav Holst
Conductor: Sir Andrew Davis
Orchestra/Ensemble: BBC Philharmonic Orchestra
Period: 20th Century
Written: 1915; England
Date of Recording: June 24/25, 2010
Venue: Bridgewater Hall, Manchester, UK
Length: 11 Minutes 33 Secs.

3. The Planets, Op. 32/H 125 by Gustav Holst
Conductor: Sir Andrew Davis
Orchestra/Ensemble: BBC Philharmonic Orchestra
Period: 20th Century
Written: 1914-1916; England
Date of Recording: June 24/25, 2010
Venue: Bridgewater Hall, Manchester, UK
Length: 49 Minutes 40 Secs.